Private Foundation Board Fiduciary Duties
Governance, Risk, and Accountability
Serving on a private foundation board is meaningful work, but it comes with substantial legal and ethical responsibilities. Many board members are surprised to learn that the IRS, state attorneys general, donors, grantees, and the public may judge a board less by what it decided and more by how it made the decision. As a board member, making informed decisions using proper due diligence is the best defense against future liability actions.
What are the Fiduciary Responsibilities for Private Foundation Board Members?
Three core fiduciary duties provide the framework for board responsibilities:
Duty of care means showing up prepared: reading materials, asking questions, and obtaining enough information to make an informed decision.
Duty of loyalty means putting the private foundation first: disclosing conflicts of interest, avoiding the appearance of “insider” advantages, and recusing oneself when a conflicted matter is discussed or decided.
Duty of obedience means staying true to the private foundation’s charitable purpose and following the rules that apply to private foundations specifically, including your governing documents, state law, donor restrictions, and key federal tax requirements.
Best Practice Tips for Board Members
- Ask for the “board packet” early: materials, budget impact, alternatives, and the recommendation (so decisions aren’t made on the fly).
- Keep conflicts visible: update annual disclosures, name any perceived conflicts in the meeting, and require recusal when an insider could benefit.
- Document the why: minutes should reflect key questions, data reviewed, and the rationale, not just the final vote.
- Use independent benchmarks: for compensation or vendor selection, rely on comparables and outside experts as needed.
- Know the “hot spots”: acts of self-dealing, taxable expenditures, excess business holdings, and jeopardizing investments all carry IRS penalties and correction requirements. Check with your tax advisor or counsel if you are not sure whether a transaction or investment falls into these areas.
- Strengthen financial oversight: approval thresholds, separation of duties, regular variance reporting, and periodic audits or reviews.
- Review Form 990–PF before filing: to ensure accuracy and proper representation of the foundation’s programs and activities. Form 990-PF is a public document and therefore a primary source of information for potential scrutiny.
- Plan for transparency: assume major decisions may be reviewed later (including through Form 990-PF reporting and public scrutiny).
Quick Checklist for Your Next Board Meeting
Confirm conflict-of-interest disclosures are current
Ask what alternatives were considered when decisions are made
Verify who is independent before a vote
Document any recusals from votes or other official decisions
Request and review supporting data
Ensure the minutes capture the discussion and rationale
How GRF Can Help
Effective governance requires more than written policies. It requires a practical framework that supports informed decision-making and clear accountability. We can help private foundations and their boards understand fiduciary responsibilities, evaluate governance practices, review related-party and compensation arrangements, and strengthen the processes used to document significant decisions.
Our team can also assist management in assessing whether internal controls are appropriately designed and implemented, help boards understand and oversee those controls as part of their fiduciary responsibilities, and provide audit, tax, and advisory support related to financial reporting and Form 990-PF compliance. Where legal interpretation is required, we can work alongside the foundation’s legal counsel to help address issues promptly and thoughtfully.
Contact us online or reach out to us at the contact info below to discuss how GRF can help you.
